Santa’s a scene stealer…
The filmmakers clearly knew Ed Gwen was going to be a classic movie Santa. Unfortunately, the focus on him leads to some wildly uneven storytelling and the careless treatment of the supporting cast dilutes really nice performances from Maureen O’Hara and Alvin Greenman, among others.
Almost everything about Miracle is corny, dated, or both, but it’s undeniably cute and charming.
Connie Willis has a fun short story that champions Miracle over It’s a Wonderful Life. That’s crazy talk. Wonderful might have a complicated and perhaps questionable conservatism at its core – as well as cinema’s most unlikely swimming pool – but Miracle’s valuing of faith over common sense is at least as problematic. I’ll take It’s a Wonderful Life any day.



